Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
  • The Weekly: One step back, to steps forward


    Brent Sirvio

    With apologies to Tom Jones fans everywhere, it's not unusual for great pitchers to take a step back on their path toward immortality. And not all great pitchers get to that place. Corbin Burnes in 2022 is going to take that step back, and we have three case studies that can help inform where he goes from here.

    Image courtesy of Benny Sieu-USA TODAY Sports

    Brewers Video

    The Weekly is a column on the Brewers. 'On' may do heavier lifting on some weeks than others.

    We shouldn't call it regression, because that's not really what it is. Regression is a deterioration -- or perhaps, for us on the outside looking in, a recalibration -- of ability.

    For example, Brady Anderson and his sideburns weren't actually as good as he was in 1996, when he hit a most-suspicious 50 home runs with a 1.000+ OPS and almost immediately regressed to career-expected numbers. Brady Anderson wasn't bad, per se; he enjoyed a 15-year career, logged over 1600 major league hits, over 600 of those for extra bases. But '96 was the exception and not the rule. He regressed. For a more contemporary example of Baltimore Orioles regression, see Davis, Chris. Side note: The good people of Baltimore deserve better.

    (And better is coming! Have you seen Cedric Mullins play? And the young guys in Ryan Mountcastle and Trey Mancini and more coming up, with Adley Rutschman in the wings and John Means anchoring the rotation? Last year's Orioles team was the best 50-win team in baseball history, and the AL East needs to take them seriously in 2022 or they're going to add 20-25 wins to last season's total. Don't look at the payroll, look at the team control. I digress.)

    With pitchers, seldom is that initial, coruscating burst of greatness sustained throughout a career. And that's where we should probably actually discuss matters germane to a site named Brewer Fanatic

    Corbin Burnes, once unfairly and cruelly maligned by much of the Packers-fans-in-summer contingency of Brewers Twitter, finally assembled an all-world campaign in 2021, fulfilling all the promise he brought as a rising prospect in the Milwaukee Brewers farm system. The numbers were gaudy, aside from innings pitched: a 1.63 FIP, 0.94 WHIP, ERA+ of 176, 234 strikeouts, 34 walks, while yielding a scant seven dingers. To mention an otherwise-impressive 2.43 ERA almost does those prior figures a disservice.

    He threw eight innings of a no-hitter, the second in Brewers history, knocking out the one leg Bill Schroeder had to stand on from his catbird seat/bully pulpit in the press box. The Brewers lost six games in which he started due to their dreadful offense, as opposed to the outright criminal lack of run support provided to co-ace Brandon Woodruff, who got squeezed by both his own team at the plate and the umpires behind it. It was appointment television. Corbin Burnes starts, that is, not the pitiful offense or atrocious umpiring.

    It's not unfair or unrealistic, though, to expect a drawback in Burnes' 2022 numbers.

    First, he won't be taking teams by surprise. The book is out on Burnes and, like reliever with changeup par excellence Devin Williams, teams can begin analyzing video to determine how to adjust plate approach.

    Secondly, good, young pitchers tend to take time in countering the counter. Let's look at a few examples:

     
    Age W L ERA GS IP H R ER HR BB SO ERA+ FIP WHIP SO9 SO/W
    26 9 6 2.69 22 140.1 117 44 42 7 43 144 128 2.67 1.140 9.2 3.35
    27 14 8 2.54 30 191.0 149 59 54 16 38 205 149 2.70 0.979 9.7 5.39
    28 7 8 3.04 24 148.0 142 53 50 15 36 143 132 3.32 1.203 8.7 3.97
    29 15 10 3.53 31 201.1 180 87 79 28 59 239 117 3.50 1.187 10.7 4.05
    30 10 9 1.70 32 217.0 152 48 41 10 46 269 218 1.98 0.912 11.2 5.85
    31 11 8 2.43 32 204.0 154 59 55 19 44 255 169 2.67 0.971 11.3 5.80
    32 4 2 2.38 12 68.0 47 21 18 7 18 104 180 2.26 0.956 13.8 5.78
    33 7 2 1.08 15 92.0 40 14 11 6 11 146 373 1.24 0.554 14.3 13.27
     
    Age W L ERA G IP H R ER HR BB SO ERA+ FIP WHIP SO9 SO/W
    22 0 2 7.15 2 11.1 15 9 9 1 5 7 61 4.52 1.765 5.6 1.40
    23 17 9 3.63 30 186.0 187 78 75 21 60 124 125 4.35 1.328 6.0 2.07
    24 18 6 3.66 32 201.2 181 88 82 20 67 183 125 3.99 1.230 8.2 2.73
    25 11 17 4.84 33 201.0 195 119 108 18 87 163 92 4.18 1.403 7.3 1.87
    26 19 9 3.45 35 240.0 219 99 92 20 63 269 131 2.80 1.175 10.1 4.27
    27 18 9 3.37 33 224.1 190 89 84 14 71 219 124 2.97 1.163 8.8 3.08
    28 24 5 2.40 34 251.0 174 73 67 24 57 250 172 2.99 0.920 9.0 4.39
    29 17 8 2.64 33 238.1 192 81 70 19 60 239 161 2.94 1.057 9.0 3.98
     
    Age W L ERA G IP H R ER HR BB SO ERA+ FIP WHIP SO9 SO/W
    20 0 1 2.25 2 8.0 6 2 2 0 1 8 163 1.16 0.875 9.0 8.00
    21 10 5 2.61 65 107.0 76 34 31 5 57 119 146 3.08 1.243 10.0 2.09
    22 11 5 3.42 24 144.2 115 58 55 11 45 142 124 3.32 1.106 8.8 3.16
    23 14 10 3.51 30 194.2 158 79 76 21 66 174 123 3.90 1.151 8.0 2.64
    24 13 10 3.70 33 216.2 189 100 89 19 70 222 117 3.27 1.195 9.2 3.17
    25 17 8 1.90 31 241.1 158 65 51 16 67 305 219 2.39 0.932 11.4 4.55
    26 19 7 2.89 33 233.2 188 82 75 26 67 251 163 3.40 1.091 9.7 3.75
    27 23 4 2.07 31 213.1 160 56 49 9 37 313 243 1.39 0.923 13.2 8.46
    28 18 6 1.74 29 217.0 128 44 42 17 32 284 291 2.17 0.737 11.8 8.88

    These are three very different, but Hall of Fame-grade career trajectories nonetheless, and all three have similar pitch repertoires as Burnes. What is clear from all three is that each of them has a pullback season, sometimes multiple seasons, where the league seems to catch up to him. Each of these pitchers goes back to the lab, not necessarily to reinvent themselves en route to the prime of their careers, but to remain a step ahead of opposing hitters.

    Now, let's revisit Corbin Burnes:

     
    Age W L ERA GS IP H R ER HR BB SO ERA+ FIP WHIP SO9 SO/W
    23 7 0 2.61 0 38.0 27 11 11 4 11 35 158 3.79 1.000 8.3 3.18
    24 1 5 8.82 4 49.0 70 52 48 17 20 70 51 6.09 1.837 12.9 3.50
    25 4 1 2.11 9 59.2 37 15 14 2 24 88 216 2.03 1.022 13.3 3.67
    26 11 5 2.43 28 167.0 123 47 45 7 34 234 176 1.63 0.940 12.6 6.88

    Expecting Burnes to duplicate or leapfrog his 2021 success in 2022 is mostly foolhardy, but that is not the same as suggesting he isn't capable of being a reliable, effective starter with the ability to sustain a strong, perhaps even Hall of Fame-worthy career. It's saying that Corbin Burnes, like Jacob deGrom, Justin Verlander or -- I would argue, the pitcher he most strongly resembles -- Pedro Martinez, will face headwinds this season to which he will will have to adjust in order to stay at the upper echelon of Major League pitching over the long term.

    And what should encourage Brewers fans is that, with Burnes' prior focus on the mental and emotional aspects of being a professional athlete, he may be particularly well-suited to not only weather the imminent storm, but mitigate its effects. So, while we might not see that superhuman Corbin Burnes this season, we will still at least see an impact starter in a corps of effective-to-exceptional starters.

    We'll be watching Burnes not in regression, but in the midst of evolutionary adaptation; changes that may well pivot him from being a top-end starter to something even more.

    Statistics courtesy Baseball Reference.

    Think you could write a story like this? Brewer Fanatic wants you to develop your voice, find an audience, and we'll pay you to do it. Just fill out this form.

    MORE FROM BREWER FANATIC
    — Latest Brewers coverage from our writers
    — Recent Brewers discussion in our forums
    — Follow Brewer Fanatic via Twitter, Facebook or email

    • Like 1
     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...