Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
  • Breaking Down The Brewers Payroll: The Infield


    John Bonnes

    You probably don't need me to convince you that the Brewers' primary limitation is payroll. We, as fans, might sort of work by feel, eyeball the roster, and expect a mid-level free agent just based on the team's history, David Stearns is doing what every business manager does: trying to squeeze juice out of every last dollar. So let's see what moves the team's payroll might allow.

    Image courtesy of © Benny Sieu-USA TODAY Sports

    Brewers Video

     

    Step one is to determine where the team sits next year because every team has players that are no-brainers to return. We can't always precisely name their salaries, but we can get close enough at a "back-of-the-napkin" level to get an idea of where the team sits and the decisions they might need to make.

    The Infield

    Catcher - Victor Caratini is arbitration eligible for one more year. His offensive performance certainly was not outstanding, but he's also reasonably affordable, expecting an arbitration award in the area of $4-5M. We'll add him to the list, especially because Omar Narvaez is a free agent. The Brewers can compete for him, but they can compete for anyone, so he doesn't make the default list. Pedro Severino also doesn't make the list since he was released by the Brewers last week.

    First Base – The Brew Crew can offer Rowdy Tellez arbitration next year and in 2024. That will necessitate a raise from his ~$2M salary this year, so we'll also jot down $4-5M for his salary.

    Second Base – The Brewers have a big decision regarding Kolten Wong. "Big" as in "$8M big." They can bring him back for $10M, or they can not bring him back and still pay him $2M. We'll add him to the list for $10M until we see how things play out overall, but understand, he's going to be on our list one way or the other: either at the second base slot or $2M in the "dead money" slot.

    Third Base – Luis Urias fits into this slot. He was arbitration eligible last year, but he's one of the few players that will get four years of arbitration, so the Brewers can do the same in 2024 and 2025, too. He also fits into the nebulous likely-to-get $4-5M category.

    Of course, the player who played the most at third base this year was Jace Peterson, but he's a free agent. We need to leave him off the list.

    Shortstop – Like others in the infield, Willy Adames can be offered arbitration, but 2023 will be more expensive than several on this list because he's a more impactful player and made a lot more money ($4.6M) this year. To be safe, bump him up to $7-8M next year.  

    So far, we have this:

    image.png

    That's $31M for about ¼ of the team, but of course, we have the big one coming up when we get to the outfield. We'll cover that next time and maybe get to some of the pitching that is growing increasingly expensive.

    If you have any thoughts about the decision the Brewers face with Wong or take umbrage (or like) any o the assumptions above, we would love to hear about them in the comments.

     

    Think you could write a story like this? Brewer Fanatic wants you to develop your voice, find an audience, and we'll pay you to do it. Just fill out this form.

    MORE FROM BREWER FANATIC
    — Latest Brewers coverage from our writers
    — Recent Brewers discussion in our forums
    — Follow Brewer Fanatic via Twitter, Facebook or email

     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Featured Comments

    6 hours ago, John Bonnes said:

    You probably don't need me to convince you that the Brewers' primary limitation is payroll. We, as fans, might sort of work by feel, eyeball the roster, and expect a mid-level free agent just based on the team's history, David Stearns is doing what every business manager does: trying to squeeze juice out of every last dollar. So let's see what moves the team's payroll might allow.

    author-tracker.gif
    adames_walking_USATSI_19135071_1500.jpg.7d947228061cc05a401a6adf23916a7e.jpg
    Image courtesy of © Benny Sieu-USA TODAY Sports

    Step one is to determine where the team sits next year because every team has players that are no-brainers to return. We can't always precisely name their salaries, but we can get close enough at a "back-of-the-napkin" level to get an idea of where the team sits and the decisions they might need to make.

    The Infield

    Catcher - Viktor Caratini is arbitration eligible for one more year. His offensive performance certainly was not outstanding, but he's also reasonably affordable, expecting an arbitration award in the area of $4-5M. We'll add him to the list, especially because Omar Narvaez is a free agent. The Brewers can compete for him, but they can compete for anyone, so he doesn't make the default list. Pedro Severino also doesn't make the list since he was released by the Brewers last week.

    First Base – The Brew Crew can offer Rowdy Tellez arbitration next year and in 2024. That will necessitate a raise from his ~$2M salary this year, so we'll also jot down $4-5M for his salary.

    Second Base – The Brewers have a big decision regarding Kolten Wong. "Big" as in "$8M big." They can bring him back for $10M, or they can not bring him back and still pay him $8M. We'll add him to the list for $10M until we see how things play out overall, but understand, he's going to be on our list one way or the other: either at the second base slot or $2M in the "dead money" slot.

    Third Base – Luis Urias fits into this slot. He was arbitration eligible last year, but he's one of the few players that will get four years of arbitration, so the Brewers can do the same in 2024 and 2025, too. He also fits into the nebulous likely-to-get $4-5M category.

    Of course, the player who played the most at third base this year was Jace Peterson, but he's a free agent. We need to leave him off the list.

    Shortstop – Like others in the infield, Willy Adames can be offered arbitration, but 2023 will be more expensive than several on this list because he's a more impactful player and made a lot more money ($4.6M) this year. To be safe, bump him up to $7-8M next year.  

    So far, we have this:

    image.png

    That's $31M for about ¼ of the team, but of course, we have the big one coming up when we get to the outfield. We'll cover that next time and maybe get to some of the pitching that is growing increasingly expensive.

    If you have any thoughts about the decision the Brewers face with Wong or take umbrage (or like) any o the assumptions above, we would love to hear about them in the comments.

    I see Caratini getting about $3M. Tellez more than doubling his salary to $4M.  Wong is gone, either threw a sign and trade or just let go. Turang ($710K) to 2B unless Stearns can do a better job and get a 3B. Then Urias at 2B, Turang as super utility (Peterson and Wong not re-signed). Urias $4.5M.  Adames $8M. That's  $20.2M or let's say $24M on the high side. 

    View full article

     

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    6 hours ago, John Bonnes said:

    You probably don't need me to convince you that the Brewers' primary limitation is payroll. We, as fans, might sort of work by feel, eyeball the roster, and expect a mid-level free agent just based on the team's history, David Stearns is doing what every business manager does: trying to squeeze juice out of every last dollar. So let's see what moves the team's payroll might allow.

    author-tracker.gif
    adames_walking_USATSI_19135071_1500.jpg.7d947228061cc05a401a6adf23916a7e.jpg
    Image courtesy of © Benny Sieu-USA TODAY Sports

    Step one is to determine where the team sits next year because every team has players that are no-brainers to return. We can't always precisely name their salaries, but we can get close enough at a "back-of-the-napkin" level to get an idea of where the team sits and the decisions they might need to make.

    The Infield

    Catcher - Viktor Caratini is arbitration eligible for one more year. His offensive performance certainly was not outstanding, but he's also reasonably affordable, expecting an arbitration award in the area of $4-5M. We'll add him to the list, especially because Omar Narvaez is a free agent. The Brewers can compete for him, but they can compete for anyone, so he doesn't make the default list. Pedro Severino also doesn't make the list since he was released by the Brewers last week.

    First Base – The Brew Crew can offer Rowdy Tellez arbitration next year and in 2024. That will necessitate a raise from his ~$2M salary this year, so we'll also jot down $4-5M for his salary.

    Second Base – The Brewers have a big decision regarding Kolten Wong. "Big" as in "$8M big." They can bring him back for $10M, or they can not bring him back and still pay him $8M. We'll add him to the list for $10M until we see how things play out overall, but understand, he's going to be on our list one way or the other: either at the second base slot or $2M in the "dead money" slot.

    Third Base – Luis Urias fits into this slot. He was arbitration eligible last year, but he's one of the few players that will get four years of arbitration, so the Brewers can do the same in 2024 and 2025, too. He also fits into the nebulous likely-to-get $4-5M category.

    Of course, the player who played the most at third base this year was Jace Peterson, but he's a free agent. We need to leave him off the list.

    Shortstop – Like others in the infield, Willy Adames can be offered arbitration, but 2023 will be more expensive than several on this list because he's a more impactful player and made a lot more money ($4.6M) this year. To be safe, bump him up to $7-8M next year.  

    So far, we have this:

    image.png

    That's $31M for about ¼ of the team, but of course, we have the big one coming up when we get to the outfield. We'll cover that next time and maybe get to some of the pitching that is growing increasingly expensive.

    If you have any thoughts about the decision the Brewers face with Wong or take umbrage (or like) any o the assumptions above, we would love to hear about them in the comments.

    I see Caratini getting about $3M. Tellez more than doubling his salary to $4M.  Wong is gone, either threw a sign and trade or just let go. Turang ($710K) to 2B unless Stearns can do a better job and get a 3B. Then Urias at 2B, Turang as super utility (Peterson and Wong not re-signed). Urias $4.5M.  Adames $8M. That's  $20.2M or let's say $24M on the high side. 

    View full article

     

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I see Caratini getting about $3M. Tellez more than doubles his salary to $4M.  Wong is gone, either threw a sign and trade or just let go. Turang ($710K) to 2B unless Stearns can do a better job and get a 3B. Then Urias at 2B, Turang as super utility (Peterson and wong nor re-signed). Urias $4.5M. Adames $8M. That's $20.2M or let's say $24M on the hgh side. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I see Caratini getting about $3M. Tellez more than doubles his salary to $4M.  Wong is gone, either threw a sign and trade or just let go. Turang ($710K) to 2B unless Stearns can do a better job and get a 3B. Then Urias at 2B, Turang as super utility (Peterson and wong nor re-signed). Urias $4.5M. Adames $8M. That's $20.2M or let's say $24M on the hgh side. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    If we have to pay Wong 8 million even if we cut him loose, why on earth wouldn't we spend the extra 2 million to keep him?

    Is this even true?  Do we have to pay him 8 million even if we don't resign him?

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    If we have to pay Wong 8 million even if we cut him loose, why on earth wouldn't we spend the extra 2 million to keep him?

    Is this even true?  Do we have to pay him 8 million even if we don't resign him?

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    35 minutes ago, John Bonnes said:

    Ugh, my bad. That was a typo. They need to pay him $2M if they opt out. Sorry. 

     

    Ok, that is what I thought.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    35 minutes ago, John Bonnes said:

    Ugh, my bad. That was a typo. They need to pay him $2M if they opt out. Sorry. 

     

    Ok, that is what I thought.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, wntrtxn21 said:

    I see Caratini getting about $3M. Tellez more than doubles his salary to $4M.  Wong is gone, either threw a sign and trade or just let go. Turang ($710K) to 2B unless Stearns can do a better job and get a 3B. Then Urias at 2B, Turang as super utility (Peterson and wong nor re-signed). Urias $4.5M. Adames $8M. That's $20.2M or let's say $24M on the hgh side. 

    Yeah, that's certainly close enough at a back-of-the-napkin level. Basically the same except subtract $8M for Wong, so about $23M. 

    I think was we get further down this list, we're going to see that the Wong money is really going to be needed if ownership doesn't decide to boost payroll for the next two years of this competitive window. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, wntrtxn21 said:

    I see Caratini getting about $3M. Tellez more than doubles his salary to $4M.  Wong is gone, either threw a sign and trade or just let go. Turang ($710K) to 2B unless Stearns can do a better job and get a 3B. Then Urias at 2B, Turang as super utility (Peterson and wong nor re-signed). Urias $4.5M. Adames $8M. That's $20.2M or let's say $24M on the hgh side. 

    Yeah, that's certainly close enough at a back-of-the-napkin level. Basically the same except subtract $8M for Wong, so about $23M. 

    I think was we get further down this list, we're going to see that the Wong money is really going to be needed if ownership doesn't decide to boost payroll for the next two years of this competitive window. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites



    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...