Article: Yovani Gallardo, one of the best pitchers Brewers fans overlook

[reillymcshane]

If you look at the career pitching leaders in Milwaukee Brewer history, there are only two players that fall in the top 10 in each of the following categories: wins, strikeouts, winning percentage, ERA, bWAR, FIP and innings pitched. One is Teddy Higuera - arguably the finest pitcher ever to wear a Brewer’s uniform. And the other guy? Sheets? Caldwell? Slaton? Bosio? Nope. The answer is Yovani Gallardo.

Yovani Gallardo was born in Penjamillo, Michoacán, Mexico, in 1986. His family moved to Fort Worth, Texas, when Gallardo was four years old. In 2004, the Brewers selected Gallardo out of high school in the second round of the MLB draft. 

It didn’t take long for Gallardo, a righty, to become one of the organization's top starting pitchers. Gallardo struck out many batters with his five-pitch arsenal - particularly his fastball/slider/curve mix. Scouts liked his poise, athleticism, and ability to go deep in games (he led the minors in innings pitched in 2006). If you wanted to nitpick anything, it might be that he walked too many batters, and there were some questions about how high of a ceiling he had.

Gallardo quickly worked his way up the minor league ladder and made his Brewer debut in 2007. Gallardo was impressive - starting 17 games while going 9-5 with a 3.67 ERA. Not bad for a 21-year-old.

The Brewers went into 2008 with hopes to reach the playoffs for the first time in more than a quarter century - and the young Gallardo was a huge part of that hype. However, Gallardo tore the lateral meniscus in his left knee in spring training - missing the start of the season. And then, on his return, he tore his ACL in his right knee while covering first base. He was on the DL the rest of the year until he was activated at the season's end. He started Game 1 of the NLDS but took the loss.

What followed next was six of the most consistent years of starting pitching in Brewer history. Gallardo - nicknamed Yo - started between 30-33 games each year, threw between 180-207 innings, and had an ERA between 3.51 and 4.14. He won 17 games in 2011, struck out 200 or more batters three straight years, and was named to the 2010 All-Star game (his only appearance). He also proved to be a quality hitter - winning a Silver Slugger award in 2010 - batting .254 with four home runs, 10 RBIs, and a .504 SLG%.

And then, before the 2015 season, with Gallardo just a year away from free agency, the Brewers made a dramatic move - dealing the reliable Gallardo to the Texas Rangers for Marcos Diplan, Corey Knebel, and Luis Sardinas.

The move frustrated many fans, who had grown accustomed to the steady work of Gallardo. However, there were signs that he was declining - despite being only 28 years old. The truth is Gallardo was one of the most worked pitchers in the league. He not only threw a lot of innings and faced many batters, but he also threw a ton of pitches.

Gallardo had an excellent 2015 season with Texas, which allowed him to ink a 2-year $22M deal with Baltimore. But the magic was gone. He bounced around for the next four years - playing for five different teams. His numbers went from solid to bad to awful (his combined bWAR in the last three years was a grisly -3.8). 

The 32-year-old Gallardo signed with the Brewers before the 2018 season, but he did not make the club and was released during spring training. It marked the end of Gallardo’s playing career. 

For his Brewer career, Gallardo played 214 games (211 starts) and logged almost 1,300 innings pitched. He had a solid 3.69 ERA, and the one category he holds the team record for is for strikeouts - his 1,226 punch-outs edging out Ben Sheets by 20. As a hitter, Yo hit a respectable .201 with a dozen HRs in his career.

Some highlights of Gallardo’s time in Milwaukee include a 14-strikeout game against Pittsburgh, a walk-off pinch-hit double in the 10th inning against Baltimore, plus a game where he tossed eight shutout innings and hit a home run - the only scoring of the 1-0 game. 

All and all, Gallardo had a very solid career - but it was disappointing in a couple of ways. First, Gallardo never developed into a top-of-the-rotation ace as many had hoped for. He had a lot of good tools and skills - but nothing exceptional that put him over the top as a pitcher. He was reliable, durable, and a great asset to the team - but he never rose to the level of an elite hurler. 

The second disappointing aspect of Gallardo’s career was his rapid decline. For seven years, he was a model of consistency and durability. Yet by age 30, he was done as a quality pitcher. 

Despite those shortcomings, Brewers fans embraced Gallardo during his time with the organization. They loved his hardworking, stoic demeanor. And they loved his dependability - taking the ball every fifth day, year after year. 

Today, Gallardo and his family, including his wife, son, and two daughters, live in Fort Worth, Texas. He was inducted into the Brewers Wall of Honor in 2021.

Please share your memories of former Brewers pitcher Yovani Gallardo.

View full article

[Brock Beauchamp]

I'd just like to say again that I absolutely LOVE this series from Reilly McShane. It's always a fun look back at players we may not think about often.

[Brock Beauchamp]

I'd just like to say again that I absolutely LOVE this series from Reilly McShane. It's always a fun look back at players we may not think about often.

[yfinn6]

I remember when he came up and made his MLB debut. Those were really exciting times to be a Brewer fan as they were right on the cusp of finally being competitive with these young players. 

I wonder if his decline was being overworked, bad conditioning, or just a combination of the two. I don't recall him ever really having over-powering stuff, but he threw his pitches for strikes. Later in his Brewers' career, it seemed like he nibbled more and more and I recall several times where he just couldn't get guys out before it was a 3-2 count with several foul balls. 

 

[yfinn6]

I remember when he came up and made his MLB debut. Those were really exciting times to be a Brewer fan as they were right on the cusp of finally being competitive with these young players. 

I wonder if his decline was being overworked, bad conditioning, or just a combination of the two. I don't recall him ever really having over-powering stuff, but he threw his pitches for strikes. Later in his Brewers' career, it seemed like he nibbled more and more and I recall several times where he just couldn't get guys out before it was a 3-2 count with several foul balls. 

 

[MrTPlush]

The 2013 DUI wasn't exactly a great look either.

I don't think people really ever appreciated Yo after that massive first half in 2010 just to have a total meltdown in the second half. Pretty sure he had an injury in there somewhere, but I think many were frustrated it looked like we had a guy breakout to be an ace and he just never was close to it again.

[owbc]

Gallardo was basically a light version of Felix Hernandez. They were born two months apart in 1986. Both of them threw a ton of innings in their early 20s and both blew their arms out by age 30. 

At least Gallardo got to pitch in the postseason a few times. He was huge for us in the NLDS in 2011. 

My last memory of Yo was watching him pitch for the Mariners in 2017. He was a shell of his former self by then and it was hard to watch. He had some rough, rough outings that year. 

[Robocaller]

I watched the game where he blew out his knee.

As I recall, some dust got in my eyes.

[Robocaller]

I watched the game where he blew out his knee.

As I recall, some dust got in my eyes.

[AKCheesehead]

I was there for his MLB debut with my Dad and my best friend who passed this spring.  We scored good seats about 12 rows back, a couple feet up the first base line, and my friend and I were pumped for the Gallardo's debut.  We paid enough attention to prospects to know Gallardo might be special. Dad was willing to take our word for it.  We were probably the first on our feet applauding the successful debut when he got taken out.

Throughout his Milwaukee career Yo was always a little frustrating.  As Reilly mentioned, he threw a lot of pitches in those innings. It seemed like so often he'd get 2 strikes on a hitter and then the AB would just go on and on.  I think that was largely what led him to such a shortened career. It also was frustrating that he  stunk against the cardinals.  Nonetheless I was always a big Gallardo fan.  He had some great games, and some really cool moments for the Brewers.  From time to time I still crack up thinking about the shaving cream pie he got after the walk off double Reilly mentioned. He was so relentless on teammates with the sunflower seeds, he had it coming and he knew. 

One other thing about that debut game against SanFran in 07.  Someone here might remember this.  Bonds hit a double off Yo in that one that was just absolutely inhumanly crushed.  It hit low on the wall on the fly and it looked like it got maybe  8-10' off the ground.

[AKCheesehead]

I was there for his MLB debut with my Dad and my best friend who passed this spring.  We scored good seats about 12 rows back, a couple feet up the first base line, and my friend and I were pumped for the Gallardo's debut.  We paid enough attention to prospects to know Gallardo might be special. Dad was willing to take our word for it.  We were probably the first on our feet applauding the successful debut when he got taken out.

Throughout his Milwaukee career Yo was always a little frustrating.  As Reilly mentioned, he threw a lot of pitches in those innings. It seemed like so often he'd get 2 strikes on a hitter and then the AB would just go on and on.  I think that was largely what led him to such a shortened career. It also was frustrating that he  stunk against the cardinals.  Nonetheless I was always a big Gallardo fan.  He had some great games, and some really cool moments for the Brewers.  From time to time I still crack up thinking about the shaving cream pie he got after the walk off double Reilly mentioned. He was so relentless on teammates with the sunflower seeds, he had it coming and he knew. 

One other thing about that debut game against SanFran in 07.  Someone here might remember this.  Bonds hit a double off Yo in that one that was just absolutely inhumanly crushed.  It hit low on the wall on the fly and it looked like it got maybe  8-10' off the ground.