Welcome to the new Head 2 Head Debate Forum - Suggest a Debate Topic

[Brock Beauchamp]

Welcome to the new Head 2 Head Debate forum! To get a rundown of the rules and system, check out the description thread.

If you have a particular baseball/Brewers topic you would like to see debated, please post your suggestions here. You may also send a PM to @Brock Beauchamp. Definitely send us a PM if you want to take one of the sides of your suggested topic to keep it anonymous. As we get suggestions and/or get debates lined up, we will post the threads and hopefully assign a start date.

[Brock Beauchamp]

To get the ball rolling, here are a few topics:

- Extend Burnes vs. Trade Burnes
- Accept Hiura Arb vs. Decline Hiura Arb
- Make Arnold POBO vs. Go Outside the Org for new POBO

[Hopper]

Neat idea, and I'll enjoy reading, but damn, seems like a lot of work.  lol

[Brock Beauchamp]

17 minutes ago, Hopper said:

Neat idea, and I'll enjoy reading, but damn, seems like a lot of work.  lol

I participated in a debate over at Twins Daily. It's a fair amount of work but not really that hard. It's like writing four long forum posts with some research mixed in to form a coherent argument.

That's part of the reason we put a word limit on the entries, it keeps the project more fun for those involved.

[clancyphile]

Go For Youth Or Trade Prospects For One Big Run In `23?

[clancyphile]

Best Brewers 2B Ever - Rickie Weeks or Jim Gantner?

[Brock Beauchamp]

20 hours ago, clancyphile said:

Best Brewers 2B Ever - Rickie Weeks or Jim Gantner?

I mean, Jim Gantner's glasses alone were worth a win or two per season.

[damuelle]

Ashby vs. Houser to commence season as #6 starter?

2B/3B Opening Day starters: (i) Turang + Urias OR (ii) Toro + Urias OR (iii) Urias + Brosseau?

[Brock Beauchamp]

On 1/10/2023 at 4:36 AM, damuelle said:

Ashby vs. Houser to commence season as #6 starter?

Ooh, this could be a really good debate! If anyone wants to participate in this, PM me and let me know which side you'd like to argue.