BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects Poll - 2017 Post-Season Edition - Voting is closed

[reillymcshane]

It's voting time again.

 

We would like to invite everyone to take part in the 2017 Post-Season BF.net Fan Community Top 25 Prospects voting.

 

Please take time and submit on this thread your top 25 Brewer prospects. Feel free to list any resources or news that you feel might help people with their voting.

 

Voting begins October 18, and concludes on November 2, which will give everyone more than two weeks to vote. You can change your votes at anytime through November 2, so I recommend getting your picks in early. You can always go back and tweak your list.

 

RULES

 

1. Submit your Top 25 prospects, in order, by end of day on Nov. 2. Put the player's full name to avoid any confusion (such as Devin Williams and Taylor Williams). Numbering them is helpful - but not essential. Also, please list your players from #1 to #25.

2. You MUST submit 25 prospects. If there are only 10 or 15 or whatever, your list will not be included.

3. You are encouraged to go beyond pick #25 - adding a few more is great. That way if someone in your top 25 is traded or released, or if you mistakenly miss a number (not uncommon), or list a guy twice, or whatever, I can just bump up your next player(s) into the Top 25.

4. Rankings are determined by total points. The top prospect gets 25 points, second prospect gets 24 points, etc.

4. As noted above, if you submit your list and want to change something, just add the change to the thread. I'll accept changes up to the deadline.

5. Within a week after the deadline, we'll publish the new BF.net Community Top 25.

 

Eligibility guidelines:

 

Rookie eligibility is determined by the same standards as MLB:

 

“A player shall be considered a rookie unless, during a previous season or seasons, he has (a) exceeded 130 at-bats or 50 innings pitched in the Major Leagues; or (b) accumulated more than 45 days on the active roster of a Major League club or clubs during the period of 25-player limit (excluding time in the military service and time on the disabled list).”

 

- Ineligible players: Josh Hader, Wei-Chung Wang

- Eligible players with ML experience: Brandon Woodruff, Tyler Webb, Jorge Lopez, Adrian Houser, Lewis Brinson, Brett Phillips, Aaron Wilkerson, Taylor Williams

- Players eligible for free agency this winter: Nick Ramirez, Hiram Burgos, Jorge Ortega, Michael Reed, Yadiel Rivera, Yhonathan Barrios, Sean Nolin - these players would have to resign - or be added to the 40 man roster - to stay with the organization. You are able to vote for them if you want, but know that there is a chance they could leave.

 

Player notes:

 

- Josh Hader has not reached 50 IP, but he has passed the 45 day mark on the active roster. This makes him ineligible.

- Brandon Woodruff is eligible as he has less than 50 IP pitched and less than 45 days on the active roster.

- David Goforth and Michael Blazek have elected free agency and are no longer with the organization

 

Prospect Rankings:

 

Please note that many prospect rankings have not been updated since mid-season - or even the start of 2017.

 

Baseball America Mid-season Top 100 (does not include recent draft picks): http://www.baseballamerica.com/minors/2017-midseason-top-100-prospects-july-7/

Baseball America Mid-Season Top 10 Brewers: http://www.baseballamerica.com/minors/2017-milwaukee-brewers-midseason-top-10-prospects/#jF71zPOW9PLAV6xt.97

Baseball Prospectus Mid-Season Top 50: http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=32224

MLB Pipeline Mid-Season Top 30 Brewers (updates as players graduate off lists): http://m.mlb.com/prospects/2017?list=mil

MLB Pipeline Mid-Season Top 100 players (updates as players graduate off lists): http://m.mlb.com/prospects/2017?list=prospects

Baseball Prospectus Top 101: http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=31160

Baseball Prospectus Top 10 Brewers: http://www.baseballprospectus.com/article.php?articleid=30902

Minor League Ball Top 200: http://www.minorleagueball.com/2017/3/27/15073602/top-200-mlb-prospects-for-2017-revised

Minor League Ball Top 30 Brewers: http://www.minorleagueball.com/2017/1/17/14297686/milwaukee-brewers-top-20-prospects-for-2017

Fangraphs Top 100: http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/2017-top-100-prospects/

Fangraphs Top 25 Brewers: http://www.fangraphs.com/blogs/top-25-prospects-milwaukee-brewers/

 

Previous Polls:

 

BF.net 2017 Mid-Season Top 25 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=35723

BF.net 2017 Pre-Season Top 25 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=35089

BF.net 2016 Post-Season Top 25 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=34747

BF.net 2016 Mid-Season Top 25 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=34472

BF.net 2016 Pre-Season Top 25 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=33867

BF.net 2015 Post-Season Top 25 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=33436

BF.net 2015 Mid-Season Top 25 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=33032

BF.net 2015 Pre-Season Top 25 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=32447

BF.net August 2014 Top 25 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=31859

BF.net May 2014 Top 20 - viewtopic.php?f=64&t=31355

 

Please note that we reserve the right to throw out ballots if we feel that the voting was done without following the rules or spirit of the exercise.

 

Thanks for participating!

[reillymcshane]

Folks, please start voting for the post-season prospect poll.

 

If you have any questions about players - such as eligibility or whatever - please post the question in this thread.

 

Also, if you notice any errors in the original post, please let me know. I will update as needed.

 

Finally, I will update the original post if there is a change (such as someone is added to the 40 man roster or whatever).

 

The post-season poll probably won't deviate too much from the mid-season iteration, but that's okay. Hader and Wang are no longer eligible, so that will open up a spot. And we got some more exposure to the new draft picks.

 

Thanks for playing!

[KeithStone53151]

1. Lewis Brinson

2. Keston Hiura

3. Corbin Burnes

4. Luis Ortiz

5. Brandon Woodruff

6. Brett Phillips

7. Tristen Lutz

8. Lucas Erceg

9. Isan Diaz

10. Corey Ray

11. Mauricio Dubon

12. Freddy Peralta

13. Jacob Gatewood

14. Monte Harrison

15. Jacob Nottingham

16. Phil Bickford

17. Kodi Medeiros

18. Trent Clark

19. KJ Harrison

20. Josh Pennington

21. Caden Lemons

22. Marcos Diplan

23. Carlos Herrera

24. Mario Feliciano

25. Nathan Kirby

26. Troy Stokes

 

I added a 26th in case someone is traded or I blatantly made an error somewhere.

[FVBrewerFan]

1) Freddy Peralta

2) Corbin Burnes

3) Brett Phillips

4) Lewis Brinson

5) Brandon Woodruff

6) Keston Hiura

7) Tristen Lutz

8) Monte Harrison

9) Luis Ortiz

10) Lucas Erceg

11) Jordan Yamamoto

12) Jake Gatewood

13) Isan Diaz

14) Phil Bickford

15) Trent Clark

16) Taylor Williams

17) Mauricio Dubon

18) Troy Stokes Jr

19) Corey Ray

20) Nate Griep

21) Adrian Houser

22) Carlos Herrera

23) Aaron Wilkerson

24) KJ Harrison

25) Mario Feliciano

[Humans Need Water]

1 - Lewis Brinson

2 - Keston Hiura

3 - Luis Ortiz

4 - Brandon Woodruff

5 - Brett Phillips

6 - Corbin Burnes

7 - Isan Diaz

8 - Phil Bickford

9 - Mauricio Dubon

10 - Lucas Erceg

11 - Corey Ray

12 - Freddy Peralta

13 - Tristen Lutz

14 - Kodi Medeiros (reliever)

15 - Monte Harrison

16 - Trent Clark

17 - Marcos Diplan

18 - Jacob Nottingham

19 - KJ Harrison

20 - Taylor Williams

21 - Nathan Kirby

22 - Bubba Derby

23 - Carlos Herrera

24 - Trey Supak

25 - Josh Pennington

[reillymcshane]

Thanks to everyone for getting things started. Appreciate it.

[OnaBadger58]

1. Lewis Brinson

2. Keston Hiura

3. Corbin Burnes

4. Freddy Peralta

5. Isan Diaz

6. Brandon Woodruff

7. Brett Phillips

8. Luis Ortiz

9. Monte Harrison

10. Tristen Lutz

11. Trent Clark

12. Lucas Erceg

13. Corey Ray

14. Mauricio Dubon

15. Jake Gatewood

16. Phil Bickford

17. Troy Stokes Jr.

18. Kodi Medeiros

19. Taylor Williams

20. Jordan Yamamoto

21. Jacob Nottingham

22. Adrian Houser

23. Cody Ponce

24. Trey Supak

25. Mario Feliciano

 

26. Marcos Diplan

27. Caden Lemons

28. KJ Harrison

29. Devin Williams

30. Carlos Herrera

 

(Edit: Thought Phillips had graduated.)

[Austin Tatious]

1. Lewis Brinson

2. Keston Hiura

3. Corbin Burnes

4. Freddy Peralta

5. Monte Harrison

6. Brandon Woodruff

7. Brett Phillips

8. Tristen Lutz

9. Lucas Erceg

10. Isan Diaz

11. Phil Bickford

12. Luis Ortiz

13. Jacob Gatewood

14. Mauricio Dubon

15. KJ Harrison

16. Troy Stokes, Jr

17. Trent Clark

18. Cody Ponce

19. Marcos Diplan

20. Taylor Williams

21. Corey Ray

22. Mario Feliciano

23. Kodi Medeiros

24. Josh Pennington

25. Larry Ernesto

 

 

Others receiving votes (j/k), would be top 25 prospects in other years, but we are so deep:

26. Nathan Kirby (injury situation but could soar if healthy)

27. Carlos Herrera

28. Je'Von Ward

29. Bubba Derby

30. Devin Williams

31. Trey Supak

32. Carlos Rodriguez

33. Adrian Houser

34. Caden Lemons

35. Pablo Abreu

36. Jordan Yamamoto

37. Jean Carmona

38. Franly Mallen

39. Gilbert Lara

40. Jake Nottingham

[Outlander]

1. Lewis Brinson

2. Brandon Woodruff

3. Corbin Burnes

4. Keston Hiura

5. Luis Ortiz

6. Brett Phillips

7. Freddy Peralta

8. Isan Diaz

9. Troy Stokes

10. Monte Harrison

11. Mauricio Dubon

12. Trent Clark

13. Jake Gatewood

14. Corey Ray

15. Phil Bickford

16. Tristen Lutz

17. Lucas Erceg

18. Jordan Yamamoto

19. Marcos Diplan

20. Jacob Nottingham

21. Trey Supak

22. Cody Ponce

23. Adrian Houser

24. Taylor Williams

25. Gabriel Garcia

26. KJ Harrison

27. Kodi Medeiros

28. Carlos Herrera

29. Mario Feliciano

30. Josh Pennington

31. Aaron Wilkerson

[TURBO]

1. Lewis Brinson

2. Corbin Burnes

3. Freddy Peralta

4. Brandon Woodruff

5. Brett Phillips

6. Keston Hiura

7. Luis Ortiz

8. Lucas Erceg

9. Monte Harrison

10. Isan Diaz

11. Jacob Gatewood

12. Tristen Lutz

13. Troy Stokes Jr.

14. Kodi Medeiros

15. Jordan Yamamoto

16. Corey Ray

17. Taylor Williams

18. Phil Bickford

19. KJ Harrison

20. Marcos Diplan

21. Trent Clark

22. Jacob Nottingham

23. Trey Supak

24. Josh Pennington

25. Mario Feliciano

 

26. Cody Ponce

27. Nathan Kirby

28. Nate Griep

29. Carlos Herrera

30. Mauricio Dubon

[LouisEly]

1 Woodruff B

2 Brinson L

3 Burnes C

4 Phillips B

5 Peralta F

6 Hiura K

7 Ortiz L

8 Harrison M

9 Diaz I

10 Erceg L

11 Williams T

12 Houser A

13 Ponce C

14 Bickford P

15 Lutz T

16 Clark T

17 Dubon M

18 Ray C

19 Gatewood J

20 Yamamoto J

21 Stokes T

22 Feliciano M

23 Medeiros K

24 Diplan M

25 Pennington J

26 Supak T

27 Brown Z

28 Ramirez N

29 Nottingham J

30 Derby B

31 Harrison KJ

32 Perrin J

33 Kirby N

34 Barrios Y

35 Herrera C

36 Clark Z

37 Ernesto L

38 Lemons K

39 Webb B

40 Wang W-C

41 QT-C

42 Lopez J

43 Henry P

44 Owenby D

45 Coulter C

46 Garcia G

47 Carmona J

48 Vassalotti M

49 Neuhaus T

50 Hummel C

 

I actually went to 100, but I don't think anybody cares.

[Greenleaf1]

1. LEWIS BRINSON

2. KESTON HIURA

3. BRANDON WOODRUFF

4. CORBIN BURNES

5. LUCAS ERCEG

6. ISAN DIAZ

7. LUIS ORTIZ

8. BRETT PHILLIPS

9. TRISTEN LUTZ

10. FREDDY PERALTA

11. COREY RAY

12. MAURICIO DUBON

13. MONTE HARRISON

14. CODY PONCE

15. TRENT CLARK

16. JACOB NOTTINGHAM

17. PHIL BICKFORD

18. TREY SUPAK

19. MARCOS DIPLAN

20. JAKE GATEWOOD

21. MARIO FELICIANO

22. JOSH PENNINGTON

23. ZACK BROWN

24. ADRIAN HOUSER

25. TROY STOKES JR

26. KJ HARRISON

27. KODI MEDEIROS

28. JORDAN YAMAMOTO

29. CARLOS HERRERA

30. TAYLOR WILLIAMS

[IndyCrew]

1. Brett Phillips

2. Lucas Erceg

3. Corbin Burnes

4. Lewis Brinson

5. Brandon Woodruff

6. Luis Ortiz

7. Freddy Peralta

8. Tristan Lutz

9. Isan Diaz

10. Monte Harrison

11. Corey Ray

12. Kodi Medeiros

13. Jacob Gatewood

14. Taylor Williams

15. Mauricio Dubon

16. Marcos Diplan

17. Phil Bickford

18. Trey Supak

19. Jacob Nottingham

20. Bubba Derby

21. Gilbert Lara

22. Cody Ponce

23. Trent Clark

24. KJ Harrison

25. Nathan Kirby

[nate82]

1. Brinson

2. Burnes

3. Hiura

4. Luis Ortiz

5. Isan Diaz

6. Woodruff

7. Lutz

8. Gatewood

9. Dubon

10. Phillips

11. Fredy Peralta

12. Erceg

13. Ray

14. Trent Clark

15. Monte Harrison

16. Marcos Diplan

17. KJ Harrison

18. Mario Feliciano

19. Supak

20. Lemons

21. Larry Ernesto

22. Medeiros

23. Lara

24. Je'Von Ward

25. Carlos Rodriguez

 

 

 

26. Pennington

27. Ponce

28. Bickford

29. Nottingham

30. Taylor Williams

 

I could keep going but I am going to stop here basically everyone from 20-whatever is interchangeable which is good and bad.

[tbbrewers]

1. Lewis Brinson

2. Brandon Woodruff

3. Corbin Burnes

4. Keston Hiura

5. Brett Phillips

6. Monte Harrison

7. Lucas Erceg

8. Freddy Peralta

9. Isan Diaz

10. Luis Ortiz

11. Mauricio Dubon

12. Cory Ray

13. Trent Clark

14. Tristen Lutz

15. Troy Stokes

16. Jacob Nottingham

17. Jake Gatewood

18. Mario Feliciano

19. Kodi Mederios

20. Bubba Derby

21. Cody Ponce

22. Gabriel Garcia

23. Josh Pennington

24. Jordan Yamamoto

25. Marcus Diplan

[molitor fan]

Can I get a motion seconded that anyone that has Monte Harrison like 14th or 15th or even lower have their response voided? thanks in advance.

[Mr Southpaw]

1. Brandon Woodruff

2. Keston Hiura

3. Corbin Burnes

4. Lewis Brinson

5. Brett Phillips

6. Freddy Peralta

7. Mauricio Dubon

8. Tristen Lutz

9. Lucas Erceg

10. Isan Diaz

11. Luis Ortiz

12. Taylor Williams

13. Jacob Gatewood

14. Bubba Derby

15. KJ Harrison

16. Troy Stokes, Jr

17. Trent Clark

18. Cody Ponce

19. Marcos Diplan

20. Adrian Houser

21. Monte Harrison

22. Mario Feliciano

23. Kodi Medeiros

24. Josh Pennington

25. Jordan Yamamoto

26. Trey Supak

27. Corey Ray

28. Devon Williams

29. Nathan Kirby

30. Caden Lemons

[molitor fan]

1.Lewis Brinson, OF

2. Keston Hiura, 2B

3. Monte Harrison, OF

4. Brett Phillips, OF

5. Corey Ray, OF

6. Lucas Erceg, 3B

7.Brandon Woodruff, RHP

8. Tristen Lutz, OF

9.Corbin Burnes, RHP

10.Luis Ortiz, RHP

11.Isan Diaz, 2B/SS

12. Cody Ponce, RHP

13. Phil Bickford, RHP

14. Maurecio Dubon, 2B

15. Trent Clark, OF

16. Jake Gatewood, 3B/1B

17.Freddy Peralta, RHP

18. Marcos Diplan, RHP

19 Troy Stokes, OF

20.Mario Feliciano, C

21. KJ Harrison, 1B

22. Taylor Williams, RHP

23. Jordon Yamamoto

24. Kodi Medeiros, LHP

25. Jorge Lopez, RHP

26. Trey Supak, RHP

27. Carlos Herrera, RHP

28. Jacob Nottingham, C

29. Pablo Abreu, OF

30. Caden Lemons, RHP

31. Larry Ernesto, OF

32. Josh Pennington, RHP

33. Demi Orimoloye, OF

34. Gabriel Garcia, 1B

35. Jean Carmona, SS

36. Payton Henry, C

37. Aaron Wilkerson, RHP

38.. Carlos Rodriguez OF

39. Zack Brown RHP

40. Nathan Kirby, LHP

41. Adrian Houser, RHP

42. Braden Webb, RHP

43. J'von Ward, OF

44. Bubba Derby, RHP

45. Zack Clark, OF

46. Brendan Murphy, RHP

47. Thomas Jankins, RHP

48. Jon Perrin, RHP

49. Chad McClanahan, 3B

50. Nick Egnatuk, 3B

[ClosetBrewerFan]

My list with a Sickel's like grading system:

 

A-

1. Hiura

B+

2. Brinson

3. Woodruff

4. Burnes

B

5. Phillips

6. Ortiz

7. M.Harrison

8. T.Lutz

9. F.Peralta

B-

10. Erceg

11. I.Diaz

12. T.Clark

13. Gatewood

14. Ray

C+/B-

15. Bickford

16. Dubon

17. Ponce

18. Supak

19. Pennington

20. Houser

21. Nottingham

22. T. Williams

23. Stokes

24. Diplan

C+

25. Medieros

 

26. C. Herrera

27. M.Feliciano

28. KJ Harrison

29. B. Derby

C

30. Wilkerson

31. Z. Brown

32. Yamamoto

33. G. Garcia

34. C.Lemons

35. J. Perrin

36. A. Pinero

37. Coulter

38. T.Taylor

39. Vassalotti

40. Je'Von Ward

41. Kirby

42. D. Williams

43. J.Lopez

44. Orimoloye

45. Brendan Murphy

[CheeseheadInQC]

Remarkably tight from 14-30

 

1. Lewis Brinson

2. Brandon Woodruff

3. Corbin Burnes

4. Brett Phillips

5. Keston Hiura

6. Freddy Peralta

7. Tristen Lutz

8. Luis Ortiz

9. Lucas Erceg

10. Monte Harrison

11. Isan Diaz

12. Corey Ray

13. Trent Clark

14. Trey Supak

15. Phil Bickford

16. Mauricio Dubon

17. Zack Brown

18. Jake Gatewood

19. Marcos Diplan

20. Cody Ponce

21. Bubba Derby

22. Troy Stokes

23. Kodi Medeiros

24. Carlos Herrera

25. Mario Feliciano

 

26. Taylor Williams

27. Jacob Nottingham

28. Jordan Yamamoto

29. Josh Pennington

30. Aaron Wilkerson

[clancyphile]

1. RHP Corbin Burnes - Sheer domination leaves no doubt.

2. OF Troy Stokes - Probably the most complete offensive threat in high minors (AA/AAA), likely to start in AAA

3. RHP Brandon Woodruff - His floor is Matt Garza 2016, which has about $12 million/year in value.

4. 3B Dallas Carroll - Looks like a Jeff Cirillo clone

5. OF Brett Phillips - .799 OPS in limited action in Milwaukee - Keon Broxton's ticket out of town

6. OF Trent Clark - Had the most walks in the entire Brewers organization

7. 2B/SS Isan Diaz - 62 BB in 383 ABs.

8. C/IF Gabriel Garcia - Bat is not a fluke, and versatile.

9. RHP Jordan Yamamoto - While everyone was excited about Corbin Burnes, he emerged as a solid rotation candidate

10. RHP Jon Perrin - Rebounded near the end of the season to post solid numbers

11. OF Lewis Brinson - Looks like he and Phillips will platoon in CF

12. RHP Bubba Derby - 3.55 ERA at Colorado Springs in 12 starts is Suter-esque sign of potential

13. OF Monte Harrison - Superb season and put it all together... but stuck behind Stokes, Phillips, Brinson, and Santana

14. IF Keston Hiura - High-average bat, but what is the position?

15. SS/3B/1B Jake Gatewood - Put it together, but where does he play?

16. 3B Lucas Erceg - The power is there, but what else?

17. 1B Ernesto Wilson Martinez - 14 of 36 hits went for extra bases, but posted 36 BB in 155 ABs

18. OF Jay Feliciano - Looks like a raw power bat

19. C KJ Harrison - Could be the best Brewers C since Lucroy

20. RHP Cody Ponce - Solid season, but others have more results or are closer.

21. OF Tristen Lutz - Showed some big numbers at Arizona, but I've been burned before by Rookie League success

22. C Cooper Hummel - Switch-hitter with pop and good OBP skills.

23. RHP Freddy Peralta - Not bad, but is he a starter or reliever?

24. RHP Luis Ortiz - Looks like a solid inning-eater

25. LHP Nick Ramirez - A left-handed pitching version of "Toolshed" Kieschnick.

26. LHP Wei-Chung Wang - Dominated at AAA bullpen.

27. UT Weston Wilson - Showed versatility and kept his bat decent despite shuffling between Appleton and Carolina

28. 1B Ronnie Gideon - 2017 was first full season of pro ball, and he was part-time in college. 2018 could tell the tale

29. OF Corey Ray - 2018 is make or break

30. RHP Nate Griep - Could make it easy to trade Corey Knebel in two years

31. C Payton Henry - Looks like a 3TO bat

32. C Josh Nottingham - I don't dislike some of his numbers, but Garcia, KJ Harrison, Henry and Hummel look to be better

33. LHP Drake Owenby - 1.062 WHIP, 11.63 K/9, and 3.32 ERA.

34. LHP Cody Beckman - 11.39 K per 9IP, 3.38 ERA

35. OF Demi Orimoloye - Like Raym faces make-or-break in 2018

[Brewer Fever]

^^^ Comically bad. It's ridiculous that it will weigh down the final numbers. Might be time to throw out the highest and lowest rankings on each player.

 

Give me a timeout, I'll accept it. That has to be trolling, a cry for attention, or both

[molitor fan]

Silvestre Berroa was released Clancy

[82brewcrew82]

^^^ Comically bad. It's ridiculous that it will weigh down the final numbers. Might be time to throw out the highest and lowest rankings on each player.

 

Give me a timeout, I'll accept it. That has to be trolling, a cry for attention, or both

 

First, I'll say that I have my issues with the lists that clancy submits and, frankly, I agree with what you are saying but at the end of the day he is entitled to his list. I guess you could argue that if he is entitled to his list then folks are entitled to criticize his list. I guess I just don't see the point and would rather folks just let him be like the crazy uncle at thanksgiving who spouts off about conspiracy theories. We all know the uncle is nuts, just carry on like nothing happened.

[clancyphile]

Silvestre Berroa was released Clancy

 

Fixed the list to reflect that.

 

Shame, he had good numbers.