How Competitive Would a AAAA All-Star Team be in the Majors?

[Crash2303]

I've always had a soft spot for the AAAA player- especially guys who dominate AAA, but never really get a fair/extended opportunity in the show. each year, it seems there are guys that break open as late bloomers or have 1-3 success in the majors around their late prime years like Brian LaHair. I wonder if a whole team of these guys were fielded against major league competition, how competitive would they be. your thoughts?

[Crash2303]

although, this team could be comprised of different players- for a plane of reference for 2015- here's an example of what a 25 man roster could look like:

 

STARTERS AGE LEAGUE OPS

RF Jose Martinez 27 PCL 1.024

C Manny Pina 28 INTL 0.840

CF Franklin Gutierrez 32 PCL 0.902

1B Matt Hague 29 INTL 0.885

LF Jerry Sands 27 INTL 0.948

3B Lonnie Chisenhall 27 INTL 0.750

2B Alex Castellanos 28 PCL 0.996

SS Danny Worth 29 PCL 0.863

 

BACKUP

Nevin Ashley-C 30 PCL 0.806

Danny Dorn-1B/OF 30 PCL 1.062

Tommy Pham-CF/SS 27 PCL 0.901

Elian Herrera-U 30 PCL 0.904

Grant Green-U 27 PCL 0.786

 

STARTERS AGE LEAGUE ERA WHIP K/9

Hector Noesi 28 INTL 3.32 0.95 7.8

Tyler Lyons 27 PCL 3.14 1.24 9.1

Andy Ferguson 27 PCL 3.21 1.1 8.8

Kyle Drabek 27 INTL 3.47 1.3 5.5

Kyle Davies 31 INTL 3.3 1.26 5.8

 

RELIEVERS age LG ERA WHIP K/9

Dana Eveland 31 INTL 1.95 1.01 7.3

Louis Coleman 29 PCL 1.69 1.01 8.9

Ramon Troncoso 32 PCL 1.98 1.10 5.2

Nick Vincent 28 PCL 3.04 1.25 12.2

Radhames Liz 31 INTL 1.40 1.06 10.4

Jhan Martinez 27 INTL 1.92 1.10 9.6

Steve Johnson 27 INTL 2.30 1.08 11

 

(sorry for the formatting issues)

[jerichoholicninja]

I guess that would be the Brewers of the late 90's and early 2000's, so the answer is: they would do pretty bad.