would you do this trade

[joshua502000]

I have Dustin Pedrioa, Aaron Hill, and Brandon Phillips for 2nd basemen....I was offered Kendrey Morales and Wandy Rodriguez for Dustin Pedrioa and Matt Garza...My first baseman are Jorge Cantu and Paul Konerko...I also already have Ublado Jimenez, Ricky Nolasco, Rick Porcello, Edwin Jackson, and Erik Bedard so I figured that Wandy is actually an upgrade from Matt Garza and Kendrey is without a doubt an upgrade at first and it allows me to play Cantu at third....Plus with the other I have at 2nd base I won't lose much of anything....Now if I can only move Aaron Hill for Braun I would be golden.

[Flood Pants]

Rodriguez isn't necessarily an upgrade over Garza. The two would give you similar numbers. So that's a wash. But Morales should be an upgrade over Pedrioa. Brandon Phillips may even be an upgrade over Pedrioa. This seems like a sound trade.

[yoshii8]

I would keep Pedroia out of those 3 second basemen, and I think you could get more than Morales and Wandy for those two.

[flosses like fossas]

the first thing i would do is counter, subbing hill for pedroia.

next, unless you've got starry eyes for wandy, i'd offer pedroia for kendry straight up.