Would you make this deal?

[fleehaw]

Would you make this deal? Is it a fair deal? Why or why not?

 

Hall (can replace Anderson in LF when Wood is ready)

Rogers/Jackson/Hammond/Parra

Mench (platoon DH & 4-5OF)

$2M

 

to the Angels for:

 

Santana

Rivera (~28 & same service time as Hall)

 

If the Angels are supposedly about to trade Figgins & Santana for Garcia & Crede, this could interest them.

 

Would your feelings change if these trades preceded it?

 

1- Clark, Turnbow, & (Dillard or Hurricane) to the Rockies for Jennings. Jennings was rumored to go to Houston for Lidge & Burke. This package is on par.

 

2- Jenkins, Sarfate, & $2M to the Giants for Hennessey & Taschner. The Giants need OFs, with or without Roberts.

 

3- Jennings, Hennessey, & (Jackson/Hammond/Parra) to the Devil Rays for Crawford. Alot to pay but worth it.

 

Is it worth giving up 3-4 pitching prospects (not Gallardo or Inman) to make these types of deals? I tried to overvalue the other teams players to help relieve my Brewer goggles.

 

I think it'd be one heck of a team, and affordable too.

[joshjs]

Jenkins, Sarfate, & $2M to the Giants for Hennessey & Taschner. The Giants need OFs, with or without Roberts.

 

I like this deal by itself.

[berniebrewer4life]

Short answer:

 

Yes, i would do that deal with the Angels.