Ian Snell?

[nate82]

I'd do Villanueva or McClung for Snell if they really want to move him. He was pretty good in 2007.

McClung yes Villanueva no. I doubt it would even take someone like McClung to get Snell from the Pirates it looks as though there are a lot of problems between Snell and the GM. Cody or Dillard might be enough to get Snell.

[shelmark]

Just because there are problems doesn't mean he is going to give him away to a division rival. That would be stupid. Cody? Dillard? C'mon guys get serious if you want a starter you have to give something up.

[nate82]

Just because there are problems doesn't mean he is going to give him away to a division rival. That would be stupid. Cody? Dillard? C'mon guys get serious if you want a starter you have to give something up.

The GM has been trying to get rid of Snell for awhile now and there has been no takers so far. I wouldn't be surprised if Snell is moved for someone like Cody or Dillard.

[endaround]

Cody and Dillard are better than McClung.

[shelmark]

Wow Nate, didn't know you were privy to the workings of the GM in Pittsburgh. Where do you get your information that he has been offered but there are no takers? Link?

[twobrewers]

If you've been following the situation and reading comments from the Pittsburgh GM - I would say Nate is probably correct.

 

Snell is owed 4.25M next year. (Along with two team options years after that) You don't pay AAA players 4.25M.

 

The GM has said several times that he regrets giving Snell that contract - refering to it as a "mistake". Now he has made comments on how Snell doesn't want to be in Pittsburgh and they don't really seem to want him back.

 

Pittsburgh is just looking to get 4.25M off of the books next year.

[Invader3K]

I hope Melvin at least investigates the possibility. He'd be a clear upgrade over Burns, and is not very expensive.

[Never Outhustled]

I hope Melvin at least investigates the possibility. He'd be a clear upgrade over Burns, and is not very expensive.

I agree. If there was ever a player who needed a change of scenary, its him. Considering how he's pitched at AAA, he could be an absolute steal. He could be a longterm solution.

 

I really hope he is aquired, and eliminates Mike Burns from the rotation.

[nate82]

Wow Nate, didn't know you were privy to the workings of the GM in Pittsburgh. Where do you get your information that he has been offered but there are no takers? Link?

From my post on the first page MLB Trade Rumors link.

[Never Outhustled]

Thats interesting Nate82. I thought Snell's stuff looked awesome against the Brewers earlier in the year, IIRC, it was the game where Gallardo's homer was the only run.

 

I'd offer Brendan Katin, and get this done so Snell can take Burns next turn. With Snell's contract options, he could be a steal if he gets himself right.

[lloydbraun]

I wonder why no team has made a move for him...those AAA numbers are ridiculous and he is in his prime. Barring his situation, he is definitely a risk, but the return could supersede that risk by light years.

[nate82]

I wonder why no team has made a move for him...those AAA numbers are ridiculous and he is in his prime. Barring his situation, he is definitely a risk, but the return could supersede that risk by light years.

It might be the mental problems that teams are worried about or the Pirates asking price but that doesn't sound like it is the issue. There maybe something else going on that hasn't been reported yet or is just unknown. Teams may also be waiting to see if the Pirates just dump Snell and sign him instead of giving away something for him.

Thats interesting Nate82. I thought Snell's stuff looked awesome against the Brewers earlier in the year, IIRC, it was the game where Gallardo's homer was the only run.

 

I'd offer Brendan Katin, and get this done so Snell can take Burns next turn. With Snell's contract options, he could be a steal if he gets himself right.

I don't think the Pirates would want another OF though. I would think they would want a pitcher in return but Katin would be almost perfect. If Snell is as good as he was or just somewhat good as he was in the beginning of the season it would be a steal. I think Snell would be just as good of a move as it would be trading for Bedard or Davis. Snell has two option years after the '10 season both years are under $10m with '12 option being the most expensive but rather cheap at $9.25m. Snell is only owed $4.25m next year also and about $1.5m for the rest of this season.

 

Snell would be a cheap upgrade for the rotation and would be at least a cheaper #4 option for next season if the Brewers would pick up Looper's option. It makes sense for the Brewers to go after Snell I'm just not sure it will happen though.

[barbados73]

Bad contract for bad contract? Snell for B.Hall, we could have to either eat some salary or send something else with Hall but it could solve 2 problems in one trade.

[TooLiveBrew]

Fwiw, the PIT tv announcers talked about Snell during today's game, & they too basically said he will be traded relatively soon. Seems like Snell is the perfect/obvious 'buy low' candidate. I'm guessing the package the Brewers sent to ARZ (Gillespie + Mercedes) would easily net Snell.

[TheCrew07]

I'm warming up to the idea of a buying Snell low, and I wouldn't mind the team making a run at Marcum or McGowan in the off-season in another "buy low" sort of move. If DM isn't looking to make a splash, then take a chance on some guys with talent but with issues, be it injuries or otherwise

[Invader3K]

I'd love to hear that Melvin is at least inquiring about him, but so far doesn't sound like anything is happening on that front.

[brewmann04]

It sounds like the very least Doug should put an Offer in for Ian. I was wondering how he would get along with the Brewers especially Braun after his comments after Karstens hit Braun.

[Hate those Rodents]

Hasn't there been a few times (maybe two at least) where Doug has made a mid-season deal as the Brewers GM with the team that we are currently playing? With Pittsburgh being willing to deal SO MANY people, you'd think he could get'er'dun with something this series.